Engagement Rings · Unique Designs

Unique Engagement Rings — Timeless Elegance Meets Modern Sophistication

Moissanite, lab-grown diamonds, sapphires, and natural diamonds in vintage and contemporary designs. Handcrafted to order in North Carolina.
117 products
  • Eilieen-dawn-sapphire-bridal-set_4
    Padparadscha Sapphire & Diamond Bridal Set
    The Eileen & Dawn
    Gold
    Padparadscha Sapphire & Diamond Bridal Set
    from $ 5,110.00
  • elowen-clementine-engagement-ring-set_1
    Aquamarine with Diamond & Citrine Accents
    The Elowen & Clementine
    Aquamarine with Diamond & Citrine Accents
    from $ 8,045.00
  • the-laurel-in-marquise-nature-inspired-oval-diamond-engagement-ring-diamond-accents_1
    Nature-Inspired Oval Diamond Engagement Ring
    The Laurel in Oval
    Nature-Inspired Oval Diamond Engagement Ring
    from $ 3,200.00

  • Have something specific in mind?

    Let's design it together.

    Start with an existing design or bring your own ideas. We'll help you take it from first sketch to the final ring.

    Start a Custom Design
  • amdir-engagement-ring-marquise-green-sapphire_2
    Green Sapphire
    The Amdir
    Green Sapphire
    from $ 2,300.00
  • beatrix-yellow-gold-oval-moss-agate-ring-front-view
    Moss Agate Vine-Inspired Engagement Ring
    The Beatrix
    Moss Agate Vine-Inspired Engagement Ring
    from $ 2,300.00
  • primrose-white-gold-oval-moss-agate-ring-front-view
    Moss Agate Three-Stone Engagement Ring
    The Primrose
    Moss Agate Three-Stone Engagement Ring
    from $ 2,500.00
  • everdeen-gold-geometric-moss-agate-ring-front-view
    Kite-Cut Moss Agate Engagement Ring
    The Everdeen
    Kite-Cut Moss Agate Engagement Ring
    from $ 2,600.00
  • titania-yellow-gold-marquise-moss-agate-ring-front-view
    Moss Agate Three-Stone Engagement Ring
    The Titania
    Moss Agate Three-Stone Engagement Ring
    from $ 2,900.00
  • CUSTOM CREATION
    Cushion cut lab-grown diamond engagement ring in 10K white gold with moissanite pavé accents
    10K White Gold Custom Dorothy Ring with 0.96ct Lab-Grown Cushion Diamond and Moissanite Pavé Accents
    INQUIRE TO CUSTOMIZE
  • Front view of The Liora white gold ring featuring a pear-shaped moss agate center stone, two pear-shaped diamond side stones, and a row of smaller diamond accents underneath.
    Moss Agate Three-Stone Engagement Ring
    The Liora
    Moss Agate Three-Stone Engagement Ring
    from $ 3,800.00
  • the-adriana-oval-alexandrite-engagement-ring-pave-diamond-setting
    Oval Alexandrite Pavé Diamond Accents
    The Adriana
    Oval Alexandrite Pavé Diamond Accents
    from $ 3,800.00
  • the-sylvestra-vintage-inspired-round-diamond-ring
    Vintage-Inspired Round Diamond Engagement Ring
    The Sylvestra
    Vintage-Inspired Round Diamond Engagement Ring
    from $ 2,775.00
  • the-eliza-vintage-inspired-oval-diamond-ring-starburst-halo
    Vintage-Inspired Oval Diamond Engagement Ring with Pear & Round Starburst Diamond Halo
    The Eliza
    Vintage-Inspired Oval Diamond Engagement Ring with Pear & Round Starburst Diamond Halo
    from $ 2,775.00
  • the-julia-pear-shaped-diamond-engagement-ring
    Solitaire Pear-Shaped Diamond Engagement Ring
    The Julia
    Solitaire Pear-Shaped Diamond Engagement Ring
    from $ 2,175.00
  • the-tessa-trillion-cut-diamond-engagement-ring-pave-diamond-setting
    Pavé Solitaire Natural Trillion Diamond with Pavé Accents
    The Tessa
    Pavé Solitaire Natural Trillion Diamond with Pavé Accents
    from $ 7,950.00
  • the-hazel-emerald-cut-bezel-engagement-ring-with-diamond-halo
    Emerald-Cut Diamond with Bezel-Set Center & Diamond Halo
    The Hazel
    Emerald-Cut Diamond with Bezel-Set Center & Diamond Halo
    from $ 3,750.00
  • the-margot-emerald-cut-bezel-diamond-halo-engagement-ring
    Emerald-Cut Diamond with Bezel-Set Center & Diamond Halo
    The Margot
    Emerald-Cut Diamond with Bezel-Set Center & Diamond Halo
    from $ 2,700.00
  • the-elenor-three-stone-pear-two-row-diamond-engagement-ring
    Three Stone Diamond Engagement Ring with Two-Row Pavé Band Accents
    The Elenor
    Three Stone Diamond Engagement Ring with Two-Row Pavé Band Accents
    from $ 4,200.00
  • the-sylvie-round-bezel-rose-cut-engagement-ring
    Solitaire Bezel Set Round Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
    The Sylvie
    Solitaire Bezel Set Round Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
    from $ 3,000.00
  • the-louisa-solitaire-princess-cut-diamond-engagement-ring
    Solitaire Princess Diamond Engagement Ring
    The Louisa
    Solitaire Princess Diamond Engagement Ring
    from $ 2,175.00
  • the-dorothy-cushion-diamond-engagement-ring-pave-diamond-setting
    Cushion Diamond Pavé Accents
    The Dorothy
    Cushion Diamond Pavé Accents
    from $ 3,420.00
  • the-tabitha-pear-halo-diamond-engagement-ring-pave-diamond-setting
    Pear Diamond with Diamond Halo and Pavé Accents
    The Tabitha
    Pear Diamond with Diamond Halo and Pavé Accents
    from $ 6,265.00
  • the-penelope-oval-diamond-engagement-ring-claw-prongs-pave-setting
    Oval Diamond with Pavé Accents
    The Penelope
    Oval Diamond with Pavé Accents
    from $ 3,265.00
  • the-harriet-oval-diamond-three-stone-engagement-ring-half-moon-side-stones
    Oval Diamond with Half-Moon Diamond Side Stones
    The Harriet
    Oval Diamond with Half-Moon Diamond Side Stones
    from $ 4,485.00

Showing 96 of 117

Filter & Sort
Clear all

About This Collection

Why Choose a Unique Engagement Ring from Rustic & Main?

Our Unique Engagement Rings collection is designed for those who appreciate unique craftsmanship and meaningful stories. Each piece is meticulously handcrafted, ensuring that your selection is as distinct as the materials used in its creation.

Whether you are looking for a wedding band that honors your heritage or a ring that reflects your personal style, this collection offers a variety of designs to suit every taste. Our commitment to quality and detail ensures a lasting symbol of your journey together.

Explore the full range and find a piece that resonates with your unique story. Every ring is made to order with care and precision in our North Carolina workshop.